Porkers.co.uk - Porsche discussion forum



Forum Home > 996-997 WET-SUMP ENGINE RELIABILITY: ENTER YOUR STATS HERE! < Post ReplyReport Abuse
1 2 3 ... 39 40 41 42

Author

Discussion

hartech
1051 posts
54 months
 Tuesday 15th June  Reply with quote
The water pump\impellors run very close to the crankcase housing and the slightest bearing wear can make them touch and break up

Baz


Ballcock
3823 posts
56 months
 Tuesday 22nd June  Reply with quote
hartech said:
The water pump\impellors run very close to the crankcase housing and the slightest bearing wear can make them touch and break up

Baz
Am I right in thinking that these impellors are made of some kind of molded plastic as upposed to much stronger materials in older water pumpers Baz?


hartech
1051 posts
54 months
 Wednesday 23rd June  Reply with quote
Yes just plastic.

Baz


kVA
1293 posts
42 months
 Wednesday 23rd June  Reply with quote
I think that's a good thing actually... Mine's just failed (on a Turbo) and the thought of lots of little bits of sharp metal circulating around the cooling system is not a good one! At least the plastic impeller is unlikely to rip through the rubber hoses and punch holes in the 3 radiator cores!


Globulator
4478 posts
68 months
 Wednesday 23rd June  Reply with quote
kVA said:
I think that's a good thing actually... Mine's just failed (on a Turbo) and the thought of lots of little bits of sharp metal circulating around the cooling system is not a good one! At least the plastic impeller is unlikely to rip through the rubber hoses and punch holes in the 3 radiator cores!
The latest cheap aftermarket pump I bought for my Peugeot 406 TDI from ECP had a cast bronze impeller on it. Bronze would give you a nice warning of failure with the noise - a small amount of bronze filings will not do any harm - we're not talking about live jigsaws here - just specks of inert metal wink

A complete impeller disappearing around the cooling system in shards of plastic would concern me far more because a) no warning = very inconvenient, b) no impeller = no cooling = overheating and/or stranded, c) Depending how the plastic shatters you may fail to fish out all the bits..

I guess a water pump is really a maintenance item rather than a 'replace when it fails' item, a bit like the timing chain on a TT.


911Fiddler
3 posts
28 months
 Sunday 25th July  Reply with quote
Re the cooling issues mantioned earlier and the lower temperature thermostats idea, an observation: even with new radiators, my 996 (early type) runs hotter, ie perhaps 10c above its normal guage level, to the point that the fans cut in, on warm days, say >18c unless roadspeed is over 45mph or so. Reason: abismal air outlet design resulting in low flow. Ie design cock-up, again. Later 996s and all 997s have slots in the front wheel arch liner to boost flow.


Risotto
2154 posts
49 months
 Monday 26th July  Reply with quote
Just sold my 58,000 mile MY2000 996 after a year of ownership. No engine problems at all.


Advertisement
Cicerosecundus
9 posts
11 months
 Wednesday 4th August  Reply with quote
Just turned 100K miles on a 2001 Carrera 4. But, when I did the clutch, I also replaced the intermediate shaft bearing assembly, the IMS, the engine and transmission mounts and a few front end parts that were worn. Runs smooth and strong. Does not burn oil. Cicerosecundus


Pugley
171 posts
29 months
 Monday 23rd August  Reply with quote
By way of adding a +ve to this thread.............
Just sold my 1998 996 C2 after over 2 years. 68k miles burned no oil, used no water, never overheated. Engine sweet as a nut.
Properly serviced and always warmed before a thrash!smile


1 2 3 ... 39 40 41 42
Forum Home > 996-997 WET-SUMP ENGINE RELIABILITY: ENTER YOUR STATS HERE! < Post Reply

Porkers.co.uk is part of the PistonHeads network